Don't Miss Out on the Latest News!


Stop extra billing, picketers urge private Vancouver clinic

August 20, 2012

CBC News

A group of doctors and health care advocates protested outside a private health clinic in Vancouver Monday, demanding the clinic stop treating patients who are willing to pay for services that are normally covered by the public system.

The Cambie Surgical Centre is one of two private clinics ordered by the medical services commission to stop extra billing. Monday is the 30-day deadline for the clinic to comply. Ryan Jabs, a spokesman for the B.C. Ministry of Health, said the province would proceed with an injunction to enforce the order "shortly," but couldn't elaborate.

"There is an issue of equity and justice there, and it's also against the law," said family physician Dr. Vanessa Brcic, who was at the protest.

'Those who can pay do pay and move to front of the line.'— Family physician Dr. Vanessa Brcic

"So we're drawing attention to that ... asking the public to be aware that the government in not enforcing, it is endorsing a two-tier health care system in Canada."

She says the extra billing is eroding Canada's public health care system.

"Because what ends up happening with clinics like these is that those who can pay do pay and move to front of the line," she said.

"What that does is provide exclusive care for them by doctors and nurses who are taken out of the public system to provide care for the wealthiest folks, and everyone else ends up waiting longer."

Last month, the medical services commission announced it had found 205 bills that were in violation of B.C.'s health care policy totalling almost $500,000.

The commission has no power to impose financial penalties or recover funds from the clinics but ordered an immediate stop to the practice.

Constitutional challenge

Dr. Brian Day, the medical director of the clinics, has said he has no intention to stop the practice. The clinics have already launched a legal challenge of the province's health care laws.

Day said he welcomes the injunction application because it will speed up his case and he's confident of victory.

An injunction would give Day a court platform to argue why he believes the service he provides is necessary.

Day was part of a constitutional challenge launched in 2009, arguing the bar against allowing people to pay for private health care violates their democratic rights.

"How are you going to argue that a 79-year-old cancer sufferer with terminal cancer should be forced to wait 18 months?" he said.

"Cause that's what they're going to have to argue."

Day brushed off Monday's protest and accused those in front of his centre of being union members concerned about health-care workers, not patients.

"The strange irony is that nearly every patient we're treating at Cambie today is a unionized worker," he said.


Click on the link below to watch Dr. Vanessa Brcic speak to the CBC about this issue:

Related Articles/Posts

  • Health care constraints...November 11, 2010 The Globe and Mail Re: Nobody Should Profit From Health Care? Get Real – Globe and Mail, November 10, 2010 Karen Selick mixes up individual...
  • For-profit Health Care...
    What does the evidence say about private, for-profit health care? It’s not what you think.   Having more private, for-profit...
  • Should we pay for blood? ...April 15, 2013 Maclean's By: Anne Kingston On March 11, federal Health Minister Leona Aglukkaq took to Twitter to issue her first public response to media re...
  • Pharmacare...
    The idea of national drug coverage, or pharmacare, has been getting a lot of attention across Canada lately. More and more people are...